Wednesday, January 02, 2013

Pierre Gagnaire (Paris) 12/2012

* Click on pic's to enlarge them

This was no ordinary night and it was to be no ordinary meal. New Years eve in Paris at one of it's finest restaurants. The streets were packed with huge crowds of people preparing to celebrate and the couple of 100 yard from the Champs Elysee to the restaurant were filled with police vans prepared for trouble.The entry to this restaurant at 6 Rue Balzac, is through the foyer of an hotel past a sitting room through curtained doors into a very spacious split level dinning area. 
Immaculately set with attractive show plates, which are use for the amuse bouche, large white clothed tables are widely spaced. These 'tables would be best suited to six diners. Decor is simple. The room is in subdued light pages of a book Talleyrand' paper the walls.                                                                                 We were four and were so far away from each other that it was difficult to have a conversation. It is a rare thing indeed to find a table too large for comfort.
                                                                              Well dressed waiters are immediately available however their English explanations about the dishes were often very difficult to understand despite several repetitions. This was not helped by the menu which was prettily presented wrapped in a ribbon at the start of the meal. It was entirely in French. Since English speaking tourists make up a significant proportion of their clients I think this could have been considered.
The amuse bouche was an elaborate four part presentation.
 Lardo de colonnata with hazelnut
Cigarette made with squid ink, filled with tuna fish and egg salmon
 Mix of green and red pepper cuttlefish sake








Parmesan short bread
 Merangue stuffed with blackberry Roman salad with anchovy
Crunchy bread dumpt sic in sweet olive oil (Santa Tea) This was the first of five breads, a different one coming with each course. Wether they were made with squid ink or mini batons or whatever, despite the two butters they were all small and extremely crusty.

Le Menu 

Caviar Beluga - cristal Grey Goose - crevettes grises. The sphere sitting on the crumbed egg yolk, adjacent to the caviar had to be gently pierced to allow the vodka to escape and sauce this dish of several layers including haddock and crab meat which was the most prominent taste. No doubt a triumph of technology I thoroughly enjoyed it although I found it more a curiosity than an exquisite experience. (8/10)                                                                                        
Corolle de Saint Jaques grillees  served'sirop d'oinon doux des Cevennes parfume de curry Madras'  sauce it was a gently flavoured dish that concealed the complexity of it's preparation, inoffensive pleasant but not exceptional. (7/10)                                   
Huitre Pied de Cheval (25 years old) I am not sure what they were endeavouring to achieve with this dish. Novelty perhaps a shock. The stress on the age of the oyster aroused sympathy  why kill a 25 year old oyster, concern, does one really want to eat this ancient specimen, and other mixed feelings. It was   
 served after being displayed,
                                             
 
in a rich bisque with abalone on a bed of green leaves. Each oyster was about as large as four ordinary oysters. It had a very strong, almost exaggerated taste of oyster and the sea. This overpowering taste stayed with me for the next few courses and really destroyed my enjoyment of the rest of the meal, a feeling shared by everyone at the table. At their request our partners were provided with palate cleansers but they had little effect.                                                                                                                                    Barquette de truffe blanche de Alba/Champignon de Paris. This was a gnocchi with a light Parmesan  flavour with a combination of several other flavours which were largely lost with the oysters we had just eaten. I would have loved to have had this on another occasion. (?/10)
Gateau de poireaux Richerenches covered in black truffle this was yet another rich and heavy dish although the langoustine were as delicate and delicious as these crustaceans ever can be. (9/10)
Pave de bar de ligne poche dans un beurre clarifie/truffe.
More truffles! Not a large dish but quite rich. The last of the oyster was slowly departing but I was now suffering from over indulgence. It would be unfair to judge this dish which was generously covered with slices of truffle which had plenty of aroma to add to the unusual textures and tastes of each thing on the plate making remarkable combination of well integrated flavours. (?/10)                                                          
Cubes de foie gras rouge oie gras was covered in jellied beetroot and served with a dom Perignon flavoured white martini. I loved this dish for both its flavours,  textures and pure fun. (10/10)
Quasie de veau fermier. When the waiter displayed this piece of veal in the pot  we expected something other than the few small bits, they were not slices, that appeared on our plates a few minutes later. Once again it was served with a very heavy sauce and one can only wonder where the rest of the veal went to.
                                                                  Le grand dessert

We were pretty frustrated by the end of the night . We had suffered through a very heavy meal, quite unbalanced, and there had been not the slightest gesture that we were welcoming the New Year. Midnight passed and that was that. e asked for the bill and a taxi. The waiter seemed almost pleased to tell us that no taxi could come because the area was closed off. Out into the rain now we were further inconvenienced  by the police who obliged us to take a detour to get back to the Metro. A very inauspicious start to 2013.
 Note this was a very special menu and not the usual except for the amuse bouche although some of the dishes may have appeared on the menu at other times. There was something of an excess of truffles with a smaller representation of those other celebratory specials, foie gras and caviar.
 Score:16/20, on this night

Sunday, December 23, 2012

Bo Innovation (Hong Kong) 12/2012

After an exceptional meal here a year or two ago I was very keen to come to this restaurant which specializes in x-treme chinese cuisine, as they put it. Sandra had no idea what to expect and was not happy when we had some difficulty finding the entrance which is actually in a side street.
They were offering a Chef's menu or a X'mas menu which, at HK$2080 was $400 more expensive and had three extra courses. That was what we selected and we were not sorry.
Many things seemed quite strange from the first thing they brought a waffle with Iberica ham and mustard sauce, which was both sweet and savoury and replaced bread, (8/10) 
 to the eight treasures that finished the meal.  Moa Tai Sour was a small sweet aperitif which was perhaps a teaspoon of foam. (6/10) .
 
The first real course was smoked eel with a strawberry sauce and some cubes of fish jelly. The eel was moist, lightly smoked and very very good though the fish jelly was rather bland and the whole dish made more interesting with the sweet sauce,(7/10)
 
 Caviar, Chinese farmed sturgeon roe with a tiny bit of edible decorative gold leaf sat atop a tempura ball containing oyster milk lying in a little bottarga, a strong fish sauce (6/10)
                                                              
 Bo Dan Dan Noodles were very spicy with red pepper                                                              
and accompanied by pine nut, preserved vegetables, salmon roe and the airiest and lightest imaginable sea cucumber foam. Beautifully presented and quite simple this nod to sea cucumber did not do anything beyond decoration for the dish although it did add one
 more texture to a complex combination (6/10). 
 Foie gras, bamboo shoot "zhou ye qing" liquor, miso, pickled Indian lettuce stem ` was slightly sweet, the foie gras barely cooked, was quite superb in this unique combination.(9/10)

  
Turkey congee, black Alba truffle, 7 year aged aquarello rice, abalone was almost the equal of the previous dish. The rice in the congee had retained some of its structure, the soft but chewy abalone contrasted with some jellied fish broth making a nice combination. (8/10) 
This was followed by a palate cleanser.  
Molecular was a technical creation. A small dumpling enclosed in a gelatine skin with a thin stripe of red vinegar condiment was designed to imitate the taste of the classical Shanghai dumpling. This was the least successful dish, mainly because of the unrealized expectation. (5/10)
  
From here on things got better and better. Tomato, presented three ways, "pat chun" chinese vinegar infused made for a sweet and delicious bite, a sort of combination with a mayonnaise added to with powdered fermented black olives, "lam lok" a green tomato flavoured marshmallow, were all astonishing simple, varied but tasteful and excited our palates. (10/10) 
Black truffle was a variation on bacon and eggs. Slices of truffle covered Chinese bacon, dried until crisp, which covered a triangle of bread on which was a scrambled pigeon
 egg. A clever idea beautifully executed. (10/10) 
 Lobster, several large pieces of barely cooked lobster meat in a lightly Sichuan pepper, sweet corn lobster bisque with tiny sweet peas was characterized by its balance. Nothing detracted from the perfectly prepared lobster nor dominated the taste of the bisque. (10/10) 
Saga-Gyu beef was a fine piece of waghu with diakon, sea cucumber, bamboo gungus, chinese yam, asparagus in an aromatic consomme, poured at the table, was stunning.  
The last of the savoury courses it summed up the character of the meal. Not overly worked, varied and satisfying in every dimension of taste, texture and appearance, one could not ask for anything more. (10/10)
Two desserts followed. Christmas spirit made up of wild turkey whiskey brownies, green tea vodka lime mousse, chinese almond ice cream, hawthorn rum, white chocolate snow and green apple martini sounds like a lethally intoxicating combination but again the tastes were distinct and everything was light and easy to eat. The brownies were exceptional but among all these flavours I expect most people would find favourite and less favoured parts of the dish. (8/10)
 
We were thoroughly stuffed by now and took the petit dim-sum back to our hotel. These eight treasures were extraordinary. Each a different taste, each a different texture but all delicate and memorable. They were made up of:  Dragon Eye gelee, coconut, Osmanthus, fermented rice, white peach, Rose macaroon, lychee, white chocolate, Lotus seed, chocolate, sticky rice dumpling, Mandarin peel, chocolate truffle, Red date marshmellow, Wolfberry, tian jin pear, blue cheese, crystal bun, Chrysanthemum steamed sponge cake. (9/10)
 
This two star Michelin restaurant does not appeal to everyone in the way it did to us. If you like imagination in every aspect of a meal, unusual combinations of tastes, wide varieties of textures within small dishes, quality products treated with respect you should love this place as we did. Service is very friendly and helpful. They have an extensive wine list, heavily marked up and a small list by the glass. We had a bottle of German reisling (HK$480 which matched well with all the dishes.
 
They would match wines if you wished.
Score:18/20 

Sunday, December 09, 2012

Chatter 47: What's Killing our Restaurants

Looking back over Epicure for the last few years I was struck by several observations. Firstly what a very good food and wine magazine it is. News, reviews, recipes articles, equipment, interviews are all first class. It's only serious deficiency is the lack of any space for comments from readers.
Apart from the constant movement of chefs there is one very frequent item of interest:established restaurants closing and new restaurants opening.  
The restaurants that close can be excellent, such as Embrasse, very good such as Verge or fated such as Garcia and Son, specialty such as Tapas y Vinos or just about anything else. No matter most have been open less than three years and are run by people closely involved with the restaurant world. 
So what goes wrong?
Clearly it's complex. There are masses of good restaurants of every complexion and every price range. Everyone knows that. Everyone must also know what staff cost, what food costs, and that set ups cost might blow out. That must be no surprise. Staff of course always come and go but even if the restaurant remains fairly popular it may still fail after a time. 
Business people are not stupid so what is it that gives them the confidence to open a restaurant or cafe at a place where several others, who also thought they could run a successful business, failed.
Perhaps this triumph of optimism over good sense arises from the simplistic conclusion that, as there are so many apparently successful restaurants run by so many people who are not especially capable it must be easy.  
Blind Freddie should know it's not easy.
For those already up and running the challenge is to survive and flourish in an ever more difficult environment. The slowing of our economy may decrease the cost of money they may have borrowed but it may also decrease the amount of discretionary spending on dining out. The holiday season may provide a temporary fillip but everything is getting more expensive, petrol, utilities, staff, produce, every thing. Work practice laws and regulations are adding more pressures. Rising costs are inexorable but diners have resistance to main courses over $49, or in many cases $39 or even less so prices cannot be put up and up to cover these costs.
People may become more cautious about opening restaurants but, regardless, the inevitable result, sadly, is that we will see more and more restaurant closures.

Sake Restaurant and Bar (Southbank) 12/2012

We have now been twice to Sake and feel quite confident in declaring it to be one of the very best Japanese restaurants in Melbourne. At the Eastern end of Southbank, under Hamer Hall it has replaced the indifferent Cafe Q.

Score 16/20
Sake
Hamer Hall, Arts Centre Melbourne/100 St Kilda Rd, Melbourne VIC
(03) 8687 0775 ‎ · sakerestaurant.com.au

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Gitane Bistro (South Yarra) 11/2012

*Click on pic's to enlarge them.


We have eaten here several times in the past and reviewed this restaurant, at 52 Toorak Rd West, under it's former name -  Fawkner Bistro. We liked it. The food was good and it was warm and welcoming. Now,having been taken over by the children of Jaques Reymond it has a more French feeling about it but it has retained all it's good qualities. The tables are  clean and neat with their white cloths,

 












 the decor is simple with a fun painting

 















and a few posters. One I particularly liked advertises the renowned aperitif Absynthe, a drink I enjoy with all the ceremony that goes with drinking it. Unfortunately it's not on the drinks menu.
  
 Service was especially friendly and helpful provided by young and enthusiastic staff. 
I started with a substantial charcuterie platter which was definitely for sharing. It was served on a panel of a box that once contained fine Sauterne.

  
 Everything on the platter was tasty but the pork rillettte was outstanding. 
A starter of paparadelles with chicken liver was a well prepared dish although we prefer the livers to be a little rarer than these were.

We tried three mains and each was excellent. A fillet of barramundi well prepared in a light cream sauce was delicate, moist with excellent 
 texture.
 
Chicken, off the bone and crumbed was also a good though rather bare dish.

 
I preferred my rump steak although it came medium rare rather than blue. The accompanying hous made sauce was particularly fine.

 A very satisfying meal.
Score: 14/20